- AImmediate inability to continue playing the game
- BA loud pop heard at the moment the knee twisted
- CA feeling that the knee shifted out of place
- DSwelling of the knee within 1 hour of the injury
- ECatching that resolves after straightening the leg
Reveal answer & full explanation
- AImmediate inability to continue playing the game
- BA loud pop heard at the moment the knee twisted
- CA feeling that the knee shifted out of place
- DSwelling of the knee within 1 hour of the injury
- ECatching that resolves after straightening the leg✓
Why Catching that resolves after straightening the leg is correct
- When a guarded, swollen knee makes ligament testing unreliable, the history carries the diagnostic weight, and the meniscus and the ACL are separated mainly by the tempo of swelling and by mechanical symptoms.
- A torn meniscal fragment intermittently displaces into the joint and then reduces, producing catching, clicking, or transient locking that the patient relieves by wiggling or straightening the leg.
- Catching that resolves after straightening the leg — a mechanical symptom specific to an unstable meniscal fragment and the finding that best supports meniscal injury here.
Why the others are wrong
- Swelling of the knee within 1 hour of the injury — describes an acute hemarthrosis; the meniscus is largely avascular except at the peripheral red zone, so meniscal effusions accumulate over 12 to 24 hours, while an effusion within the first 2 hours predicts ACL rupture in roughly 70 percent of cases.
- A loud pop heard at the moment the knee twisted — classic for ACL rupture and reported by about half of those patients, whereas meniscal tears more often produce a subtle tearing sensation.
- Immediate inability to continue playing the game — reflects the gross instability of a ruptured ACL; patients with isolated meniscal tears usually finish the activity and stiffen later.
- A feeling that the knee shifted out of place — giving way is easy to file with the mechanical symptoms of a meniscal tear, but a sensation of the knee shifting out of place reflects true instability of the tibia on the femur from a ruptured ACL; meniscal tears more often cause brief pain-related buckling without a shift, so this history favors the ligament.
Terminal extension loss can occur with either injury and does not discriminate, though a true springy block to extension suggests a displaced bucket-handle tear. Joint line tenderness and the Thessaly and McMurray maneuvers should be checked once guarding settles, and MRI is used for confirmation.