- ASubarachnoid hemorrhage
- BReversible cerebral vasoconstriction syndrome
- CCervical artery dissection
- DTraumatic lumbar puncture
- EViral meningitis
Reveal answer & full explanation
- ASubarachnoid hemorrhage✓
- BReversible cerebral vasoconstriction syndrome
- CCervical artery dissection
- DTraumatic lumbar puncture
- EViral meningitis
Why Subarachnoid hemorrhage is correct
- Thunderclap headache (sudden maximum-intensity onset) is subarachnoid hemorrhage (SAH) until proven otherwise
- CT sensitivity is ~98-100% in the first 6 hours but declines to ~85% at 24 hours, so a negative CT obtained later does not rule out SAH
- After a negative CT obtained more than 6 hours from onset (or with a new neurologic deficit), lumbar puncture (LP) is indicated; a negative high-quality CT within 6 hours in a neurologically intact patient can exclude SAH
- Xanthochromia (yellow CSF from hemoglobin breakdown) can begin within a few hours but is reliably present only about 12 hours after the bleed, and persists for about 2 weeks
- Non-clearing RBCs (RBCs do not decrease from tube 1 to tube 4) support true SAH over a traumatic LP, but tube-to-tube clearing is unreliable, so xanthochromia is the more reliable discriminator
- Most common cause of spontaneous (nontraumatic) SAH: ruptured saccular (berry) aneurysm (85%) — anterior communicating artery is most common
Why the others are wrong
- Viral meningitis — CSF would show pleocytosis, not xanthochromia and non-clearing RBCs; onset is typically not thunderclap
- Reversible cerebral vasoconstriction syndrome — also causes thunderclap headache, but the CSF is typically normal without xanthochromia
- Cervical artery dissection — a real cause of abrupt severe headache in a young adult, but it usually brings neck pain, a partial Horner syndrome, or ischemic deficits, and an extracranial dissection leaves the CSF clear rather than xanthochromic with non-clearing red cells
- Traumatic lumbar puncture — the usual benign explanation for red cells after a negative CT, but tube-to-tube clearing is unreliable and xanthochromia is the better discriminator: it forms as hemoglobin breaks down in the subarachnoid space over hours, so it marks blood present before the needle rather than blood introduced by a fresh traumatic tap, and the RBCs here also do not decline
Additional high-yield points
- CT angiography (CTA): sensitive (above 95%) for aneurysms above 3 mm — first-line non-invasive vascular imaging
- Catheter angiography (digital subtraction angiography (DSA)) is the gold standard if CTA is negative
- Treatment: urgent neurosurgical consultation; aneurysm securing by clipping or coiling (ISAT trial: coiling superior for eligible aneurysms)
- Nimodipine 60 mg PO q4h x21 days reduces delayed cerebral ischemia
- Additional management: strict BP control; euvolemia; avoid fever; monitor for hydrocephalus